On this episode, Andy Moore talks with Keith Gaddie about what happened on Election Day. Andy describes a nationwide 'blue tsunami,' and Keith frames the results as a rebuke of the president, amplified by candidate quality and a damaged party brand. Keith points to a striking drop in turnout among white evangelical voters, and both agree that if a party is hard enough on its own base, that base may simply stay home.

Much of the conversation lands in the South. They walk through Texas, including Ken Paxton's troubles, James Talarico's faith-rooted 'bless your heart' campaign style, Gina Hinojosa's ground game, and shifts among young, Hispanic and Black voters. Keith shares a conversation with a conservative Latino rancher in the Rio Grande Valley. They then turn to Mississippi's still-uncounted Senate race between Cindy Hyde-Smith and Scott Colom, a 'pick another protein' gaffe, and how mail-in, provisional and recount rules work there compared with Oklahoma.

Closer to home, they look at Oklahoma's suburban shifts in places like Edmond, why the state's electorate is less diverse than its population, how the redrawn 5th District held, and Mayor David Holt's post-election comments about cities and state preemption. Keith argues that kitchen-table issues outweighed culture-war ads this cycle, and that polls got the direction right but missed the magnitude. With a delicious season for irony behind them, Andy previews an upcoming episode with Emily Stacey focused on Oklahoma's races and low turnout.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 First episode since the election
  2. 3:19 Why evangelical voters stayed home
  3. 6:06 Texas: Paxton, Talarico and Hinojosa
  4. 18:27 Populism and kitchen-table politics
  5. 23:09 Mississippi's Senate race and the slow count
  6. 31:41 Oklahoma's suburbs, demographics and gerrymandering
  7. 42:51 David Holt, cities and growth corridors
  8. 53:24 Regional differences and wrap-up
Read the transcript

Transcribed automatically, with speakers added by AI. It may have mistakes; the recording is the record.

Andy Moore0:00Welcome to Let's Pod This. My name is Andy Moore. Friends, it's good to be with you. It's election week and this is our first episode since the election. I'm joined by my good friend Dr. Keith Gaddy. Keith, welcome. Thanks for being here.

Keith Gaddie0:22Good to be here, Andy.

Andy Moore0:24Always good to see you. Thanks for coming back. What a week, right? So here's the top lines as we know them. It's a blue tsunami, right? Blue tsunami. Democrats across the country had a forceful, a generational victory, I think. 94% of counties in the United States moved to the left. They have flipped, Democrats have flipped over 500 state legislative seats,

Andy Moore0:50giving them control of a majority of state legislatures, which they haven't had in decades. Texas is blue, we'll talk about that. Kansas went blue. Missouri, Mississippi, I mean, the South, that map from the New York Times,

Andy Moore1:05all the little arrows pointed, It's just a, it looks like a sea of blue to the left. I guess my question is to start, like, what happened?

Keith Gaddie1:14Well, you know, it's funny, on election night, I got to ask the question, is this election a rebuke of Donald Trump? Or is it something else? And I said, yes, it's a rebuke of Donald Trump. Because the president made the campaign about him personally. There's a lot that loads into that, okay?

Keith Gaddie1:35The rebuke's not enough. You have to have candidates available to vote for, and you have to have candidates that are attractive. And both the attractive Democratic candidates and the unknown Democratic candidates won. And a lot of these states, what happened is the combination of a good Democratic candidate with presidential unpopularity plus bad Republican candidates further enhance the impact.

Keith Gaddie2:00But the funny thing is, as we'll discuss, is what you see when you look state after state after state is whether you're a highly visible candidate or an unknown candidate, you ran similarly strong as a Democrat up and down the ticket. Which makes you think that it's something much more fundamental, which is the environment and the GOP brand and the presidential brand were all loaded together and deeply damaged in the eyes of the American public and they voted against all the politics they've had

Keith Gaddie2:30last two years, if not the last 10.

Andy Moore2:32Yeah. Yeah. I mean, someone, I was listening to another podcast and I think it was Mary Ratcliffe from 50 Plus One, I think it was her, who said, you know, this election tells us that if you anger your base, they will stay home. Right?

Andy Moore2:51And that's, I mean, at least here in Oklahoma, and this is one of the metrics we've been looking at, is that turnout in Oklahoma was down. Yeah. There was enthusiasm early on, especially among left-leaning voters, but across the country, we did see, like, it seems like a depression of turnout among hardcore Republican voters who just maybe felt like abandoned, I guess, by their party, or I don't know, candidate

Andy Moore3:17quality, I think, is an issue.

Keith Gaddie3:19Yeah, and if you want a good, illustrative example that's got durability in American politics. The foundation for the GOP for the last 32 years has been evangelical white Christian voters, right? Phenomenals, evangelical and biblical literalists, they all kind of get bundled together, okay? And they consistently for the last 32 years have voted 82 to 84% Republican. And this last election they voted 82 to 84% Republican state after state after state. But here's what's interesting. You go back to the presidential election in 2024, 24% of the GOP vote came from white evangelical Christians or various other versions of that, various flavors of evangelism.

Keith Gaddie4:03This cycle, it was 17% of their vote, came from those voters, okay? And if you dig even deeper, what that means is if you account for the level of turnout, right, and the overall vote, what it means is that about half of the evangelicals who would have voted

Keith Gaddie4:23in 2024 stayed home this year. And usually these are pretty consistent voters. It's not just as they voted at a lower rate. It's either they were a smaller part of the turnout. they were a much smaller part of the vote. They were a small part of the GOP's electoral base

Keith Gaddie4:38and a much smaller part of the overall turnout. Now, part of that is admittedly that there has been some attrition in that group. Okay, there was a decline among identifiers, but a lot of them just stayed home. Okay, they got their court in 2024, right?

Keith Gaddie4:52They got their SCOTUS. And now they look and they said, I don't know if I have a lot of reason to support this anymore. So they just stayed home. And I think it feeds into what you said.

Keith Gaddie5:02If you're hard enough on your base and you hurt them enough through public policy, you give them no positive reason to be there, they don't show up.

Andy Moore5:09Yeah. Yeah. That's really interesting. I mean, I think we don't have all the data yet, obviously, and some states are still counting votes as well, but I'll be really curious to see

Andy Moore5:19the generational turnout, right? I mean, obviously older voters turn out at a higher rate than younger voters, but it feels like there's a shift in power happening from the baby boomer generation down to Gen X and even millennials who are starting

Andy Moore5:35to like feel, I mean directly feel the pinch of some of these economic policies and the tariffs and gas prices and the cost of the war and its impact on global economic situations. And that while that hurts kind of everybody, if it hurts enough that the older voters decide

Andy Moore5:54to be like, wow, this guy's corrupt, I'm just not even going to show up. Because I think a lot of conservatives would say, Like I'm mad at what's happening, but I'm sure as hell not going to vote for a Democrat. I'd rather just not vote at all.

Andy Moore6:06And in places like Texas, and maybe we should talk about that state first. I mean, let's start with candidate quality. Ken Paxton was a terrible candidate. Even by, like Republicans would acknowledge it. I mean, the president was making fun

Andy Moore6:19of the way he looks in public. And I've heard multiple pundits say, if you can come up with an idea for a scandal, Ken Paxton had that scandal happen to him.

Keith Gaddie6:30Yeah, and you know, Ken Paxton, let's mind you, Ken Paxton was the incumbent attorney general of Texas, right? He had been in that office for a while. And another thing we ought to acknowledge real quick, okay? There's this thing called lookism, right? And we always criticize Donald Trump

Keith Gaddie6:47for making fun of people's looks or making fun of their disabilities. Ken Paxton has a droopy eye, okay? Ken Paxton has some disabilities that physically manifest, right? It's remarkable that he got elected in the face of look ism right then

Keith Gaddie7:03It's amplified by the president through the president's peculiar sense of humor, right? but Ken Paxson has Literally, we won't even recount it here if you could put together The laundry list of the things that work against the candidate Ken Paxson had it had he been like Impeached as well. He was impeached by the state house by the Republican House in Texas

Keith Gaddie7:27And a majority of the Senate voted to convict him, but they didn't have quite enough votes to bring it home. And so they took a pass on convicting him. So he's already damaged by that, right? Yet nonetheless, he still is able to win a party a party run off against an incumbent US senator John Cornyn. Normally a very popular stable traditional sort of movement conservative. You typical Texas Republican, right? You know, so he's coming out of that situation and normally you say, hey, you beat an incumbent,

Keith Gaddie8:00you got power going forward. But it deeply divided the GOP to the point where eventually all the Bush family came out in support of James Talrico. They all came out also against a guy named Beau French who was the GOP nominee for railroad commission who was a highly controversial and inflammatory Republican County chair in Tarrant County, Texas.

Keith Gaddie8:20You got a lot of stuff going on in Texas that hurts Republicans and emboldens Democrats. But James Talrico is one of these once in a generation young candidates. And what's fascinating about Talrico, should we go there real quick? Yeah, I think so. I don't want to wander off the reservation on you.

Andy Moore8:41No, no, I think we should talk about Talrico as well. And we'll start with lookism. It doesn't help that he was a very young, handsome, like vibrant looking young man.

Keith Gaddie8:49He's young and he's handsome and he's colorful and he doesn't fit the cowboy image that people think is the only expression of being Texan.

Andy Moore8:59But he was a white evangelical Christian who used his faith.

Keith Gaddie9:03But not in the... He's not evangelical.

Andy Moore9:05He's Presbyterian.

Keith Gaddie9:06Oh, okay. He's a Presbyterian seminarian. He grew up Baptist in South Texas, but he's Presbyterian. He's very mainline. But the thing is, he does that thing that you can't beat. The man knows how to play Bible,

Keith Gaddie9:20knows how to talk Bible, and he does it well. And he speaks from a biblical tradition and a Christian tradition, consists with his seminarian training, right? And it stands in contrast to other versions of Christianity we think about in politics.

Keith Gaddie9:38But it resonates especially even with younger evangelicals because he's talking about the message of Christ, okay? He's talking about those good works and those good things we do, right? He really is talking about New Testament scripture, which he can Old Testament contextualize with no trouble.

Keith Gaddie9:57So it's not a fire and brimstone control authority Christianity. It's very much that theology of love, right? And he speaks in that voice. And every time you put a negative attack on him and you saw him respond or heard him respond,

Keith Gaddie10:16it was in the best Southern Tonable bless your heart. And then he would just flip it on his head through a positive, right? Or through a cutting critique that still sounded positive. When he indicated that Kim Paxton, who was born in California,

Keith Gaddie10:31anyone can be a Texan, even my opponent, who's from California, as an eighth generation Texan, I can say, you can't beat this guy.

Andy Moore10:41No, and that reminded me of Ronald Reagan, right? of saying, I'm not going to let my opponents, I'm not going to use my opponent's youth and inexperience against him. When he was trying to make jokes about Reagan being old. And I was like, that was such a good way to turn it around.

Andy Moore10:56And same thing, some reporter was trying to get Talarico to talk about Ken Paxton and how he felt about him. And Talarico just said, well, he's my brother in Christ, but I'll tell you when he's wrong. It was just the wrong, he's like, I love him,

Andy Moore11:09but he's wrong on these things. And I was like, it was such a kind way to highlight the difference between the two candidates.

Keith Gaddie11:17And you know, it leads to a politics where maybe you can stay on policy and issues, or even upon the intention of the heart, right? The intention of the heart, you can stay on these things. And it resonated with voters. So you have this bit of having

Keith Gaddie11:36Tauricos and attractive candidate, but also Gina Hinojosa, the Democratic nominee for governor, Izzo state lawmaker from down in Austin, but you grew up in the South Valley, okay? Latina, lawyer, right? Attractive, effective, strong campaigner.

Keith Gaddie11:53But she ran under radar. She wasn't truly visible in the legacy media, but she had a really good contacting game, a really good campaign on the ground. And so with Talrico running strong, she can ski in that wake.

Keith Gaddie12:06And then they compliment each other, because if you're activating for Talrico, implicitly you're activating for folks behind them. Sure. Thing is, once she gets legs, and her poll movement started about a month before the election, and you'll recall, you and I kind of talked about this stuff a little bit offline.

Keith Gaddie12:20You need to watch this candidate. Yeah. And we still weren't certain if she was going to win going into election day, but man, she looked strong. So she gets legs, and then the Democratic opponent for Lieutenant Governor gets legs against Ann Patrick.

Keith Gaddie12:34The railroad commissioner, you know you're in trouble in Texas, okay? You know who you're in trouble in Texas when, oh Lord, what's the name, Bush's Numbers guy?

Andy Moore12:46I'm having these moments. Oh yeah, Carl Rove.

Keith Gaddie12:49Carl Rove, thank you. Thank you. I'm not ancient yet, but I'm working on it, okay? You know, when Carl Rove comes out and says, I can't vote for you, I'm gonna vote Democratic for the first time in my life,

Keith Gaddie13:00you know, they threw Carl out there as the first, as the first, as the first test on this, and then the Bush has skied and Carl's wake. He's in trouble. Here's what's funny, Andy. When the vote came in, everybody ran about the same.

Keith Gaddie13:17Taurico was the strongest among the Democrats. And therefore, Paxton was the weakest Republican. Every other statewide Republican running, they all lost. And their vote all clustered about two points better than Paxton altogether, including controversial candidates.

Keith Gaddie13:36It didn't matter if you were controversial or not. Once that vote started at the top, it was going democratic, it went all the way down to the bottom.

Andy Moore13:44Yeah. Well, and in Texas, it translated to not just these elected positions, but the courts, right?

Keith Gaddie13:50I think the state supreme court. Every state supreme court, a half the state supreme court was up. Those positions all went.

Andy Moore13:57Yeah. So they went from a, I think from a 9-0 court to a 5-4 court. The state board of education flipped.

Keith Gaddie14:03Yep. and tons of other down ballots. Quarter criminals appeals, the state legislature, the Democrats went from having a 10 seat minority to a nine seat majority. Right now they're still counting, right?

Keith Gaddie14:15At one point we thought they might give the state Senate too but only half the Senate was on the ballot. So the Democrats run strong in 28, which we don't know, we don't know. But if they run strong in 28, they could end up with unified democratic government

Keith Gaddie14:29in Texas. That's wild. Yeah, but the other thing I meant to tell you, The other thing I saw, and this is part of Hina Hosa and also James Talrico, you had asked earlier about young voters, right? We know from the exit, okay, we know from sign in data that first time vote and young

Keith Gaddie14:49vote was very high, okay? Higher than usual. We also know that African American vote and Hispanic vote, both in Texas and around the country was much higher, okay? not at record levels, especially for a midterm. You look at Texas in my in 2024, how old am I 19 in 19 in 2024, a bare majority of Hispanics voted for

Keith Gaddie15:18Donald Trump for president. Then when they drew the new congressional districts part of how they baseline them was based upon the assumption that those Hispanic votes have been banked by the GOP that they'd be there again. Okay, it creates all this vulnerability in the district south of I-10. You get to the election, you get to the election in 2026, that vote went back to the Democrats.

Keith Gaddie15:44At a little bit better than a three to two rate, if you will, you leave the exit polls. The young vote, which had barely gone for Donald Trump in 2024, went about 70% for the Democrats, right? So all these constituencies that have been there in 2024 they went away. They went back to where they had been generally voting, but

Keith Gaddie16:05with higher turnout levels also. In South Texas I was in the lower Rio Grande Valley about two weeks before the election. And I get talking in, I'm not going to say which caddy because I'm going to out the guy too quickly, I'm in one of the lower Rio Grande Valley courthouse towns and I'm talking to a bailiff, okay? And he's also a rancher. had been a Texas Ranger. He's a Latino. He's conservative, self-professed conservative, but we're standing there and we're looking down towards the river and he says, I don't

Keith Gaddie16:37like that wall. He said, you don't need that wall to do the job. And he said, ICE, when ICE first came along, they were just taking care of the border. Yeah, that's fine. We needed to do that. They moved to these other areas, right? So what happened is these policies the last two years really hurt Hispanic families, even Hispanic conservatives. And it caused these votes to go back. And I think once burned twice shy, I doubt that vote comes back.

Keith Gaddie17:07I think the Democrats, if they do everything right, they're going to be able to bank that

Andy Moore17:11vote for a while. Well, and that's the big question, right? Is that in a lot of these races, and I don't know all the margins in Texas, but a lot of these seats that flipped didn't necessarily flip by a huge margin, individual races. So in the Oklahoma state legislature, the Democrats flipped six House seats, but several of those were by fewer than 500 votes.

Andy Moore17:31So these are, they flipped a 26 year old or a 29 year old by a few hundred votes. That's a seat that is still very purple. Some of them we thought were pretty solidly red. They would now learn it in purple, but that also means that the onus is now on the other foot. So for the Democrats, especially in places like Texas, to say, you know, we voted

Andy Moore17:51for you because we're mad at the other guys, but you got to perform otherwise, you know, we can stay home or go back.

Keith Gaddie17:56Well, and this means that one of the things for democratic activists, they have to accept the fact that if you want to govern or be part of governing, you're going to have to accept moderation.

Andy Moore18:07Yeah.

Keith Gaddie18:08That doesn't mean watering down. It means that somebody's going to be there with you on many issues or even most issues, but not all issues. Welcome to governing.

Andy Moore18:17Right. Welcome to governing.

Keith Gaddie18:19This is what you have to, this is what grownups do is they make deals. Okay, you compromise from time to time and then you try and move your way towards the thing you want. Okay, so

Andy Moore18:27Yeah on that note You know looking at candidates Like Talarico, but maybe Ossoff but more like Abdu'l Said up in Michigan and some of these other like Populist candidates, right? Progressive maybe but like they've been identifying this being a populist

Andy Moore18:47This is my thing. And lots of questions from the media about what does that actually mean? And maybe a good example is Mayor Mamadami in New York City who was not on the ballot this year, but certainly now definitely looks like

Andy Moore19:04an early warning sign that the Republicans should be heeding that a policy platform that speaks to the heart of the everyday person is much more compelling to everyday people than this culture war, you know, trans kids in sports, blah, blah, blah,

Andy Moore19:22that just fell flat. And it seemed like after a few years of, you know, Trumpism in America, that voters were over it. They were like, this stuff doesn't matter. Our lives are getting worse. And so in comes this populist message.

Andy Moore19:38Not, but to me, it's not, I mean, there is some anger there, but it's not the kind of like angry pitchfork populism that I think a lot of us think about. It was more of just like, just be normal. Just fix the thing that's broken

Andy Moore19:50and make life better for all of us.

Keith Gaddie19:54Am I missing something in there? No, no, and you remember probably about a year ago, you and I had talked about defining democracy and that work that Kirby Goydell and Nick Davis and I had done. The sweet spot in the American public is that centerism with just enough of a safety net

Keith Gaddie20:10to make life not hurt too much, right? We've gotten to the point of the last couple of years, we've been told by conservatives, life's hard and it's gonna hurt. And here's some pain for you if you didn't have any. Forgive me.

Keith Gaddie20:27If you make the working class worse off, right? You make the working class worse off. If you make the middle class worse off, you make the upper middle class less upper middle class, you've pushed a lot of people in a direction where they're looking around and going,

Keith Gaddie20:42Yeah, I think I'll have some of that socialism there. Maybe we need to think about the cost of all these things and who's getting rich. And there are times where I'd look at Donald Trump and I'd think, this is the best democratic spokesperson I've ever seen.

Keith Gaddie20:57We're making record money. We're making record, I'm not gonna do that, sorry, but. We're making record money on oil, on gas, corporations, the DOWs at 53,000, all these things. Right? Most people aren't feeling those benefits because, yeah we're making lots of money on

Keith Gaddie21:17the tariffs because those taxes are being paid by Americans. You weren't doing anything that made most people feel like they were better off. And then you came back in your campaign and tried to play culture war again and it fell flat. And then you have to ask why. because scaring people over culture war issues

Keith Gaddie21:43doesn't work really well when you're sitting at the kitchen table trying to figure out which bills you're gonna pay. And that has dug deeper and deeper into Americans, dug deeper and deeper into rural America. And we can dig into that a little more if you want to.

Keith Gaddie22:00But yeah. I mean, let's kind of go. We can come to that later.

Andy Moore22:03We talked about Texas, and I'm sure we could spend three hours on that state alone.

Keith Gaddie22:07They'd love that.

Andy Moore22:09They would. And I will say, as a native Texan, I grew up there. I have it tattooed on my arm. But I haven't felt the Texan pride that I did when I was growing up until this. And the moment that it happened was the morning

Andy Moore22:22after the election, Wednesday morning when I opened Instagram and saw that photo of Talarico and Inahosa at Water Burger. And I was like, this is genius. And it made me, because Water Burger is from Texas, And I'm like, well, the quality is not what it was

Andy Moore22:37when I was a kid.

Keith Gaddie22:38That scene with the cups and a fast food measure. You know those are Dr. Peppers also.

Andy Moore22:43Oh, of course, right. Absolutely, yeah. But it was such the exact right image for the exact right people, the exact right election. And I was like, someone, some strategist, whoever came up with it, got it in just the right way.

Andy Moore22:58And I was like, okay. Because you felt people being happy again and celebrating a state that has been punitive for so many people for a number of years. So let's shift over into the South some more. I know we can talk about Georgia as well,

Andy Moore23:13but let's start with Mississippi. Oh yeah. Because the votes are still being counted. I'm getting ads from both candidates trying to raise money to help pay for this count. But so it's between incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith,

Andy Moore23:28Yeah, I was a Republican and and her challenger Scott column Scott column and who is a black man. She's a woman. And I just will start by saying it was as recent as 2020 that the state of Mississippi had the Confederate flag on their flag. And here we have them electing yes, a statewide race, potentially going to a black man. That is right quite a shift in just a few

Keith Gaddie23:55years. It is. I mean, we used to say of southern politics, if not the nation, every other southern state can fall back on the sole satisfying explanation. Thank God for Mississippi in part because it proved that surely it could be worse, right? It could be worse. You can always look at Mississippi and say, thank God that ain't us. Mississippi is wonderfully surprisingly shockingly here in an unanticipated change. It's only like three weeks ago this thing really showed up on everybody's radar.

Keith Gaddie24:30And it was when the incumbent had a misstatement about red meat prices. She said the most un-Mississippi thing you could ever see, there are other proteins. Right. Pick another protein. Okay. Is that not the most vegan thing you had ever heard?

Keith Gaddie24:46You don't have to eat animals. There are other proteins, right? You know, we have legumes, right? You mean you'd be a legume Republican. Right.

Andy Moore24:53Yeah. But that ad, the video where they had all those people just saying, pick another protein, she ate it. Like, I was like, this was the message that resonated with voters in a very personal way because it was absurd. Yes.

Andy Moore25:08the suggestion was absurd and it did sound like something that five or ten years ago we would have assumed it was a Democrat who said that for whatever reason.

Keith Gaddie25:16But it illuminated a larger issue and illuminated an issue that's also a Texas issue in a different way which is cattle ranching and ranchers suffering and the repopulation of the herd and all these things. So we'll put a pen on it. Back in Mississippi. So what happens is Cynthia Hyde-Smith

Keith Gaddie25:35was a relatively new incumbent senator. And a couple of years back, Scott Column was nominated by Joe Biden for a place, I think it was by Biden or Trump, for a place on the federal district court. Well, in the US Senate, there's a thing called the blue slip.

Keith Gaddie25:52And as a senator from a state, you're supposed to return a blue slip to indicate that you've endorsed the nomination this person for a federal position on the bench or as a federal marshal. She did not return her blue slip. Now Roger Wicker, the other Republican, did. He did return the blue slip on Scott Collum. And by not returning the blue slip, that just stopped his nomination.

Keith Gaddie26:16That's a veto point, okay? This is part of what's called senatorial courtesy. It's an old norm and we still follow it. Well, that's when she bought an opponent. And and honestly none of us were really paying attention because it's Mississippi. Most polarized racial voting in the US even though it has by percentage

Keith Gaddie26:36the largest African American population in the US, right? The last time Mississippi elected a national liberal or even a national moderate to US Senate was never, okay? The last Democrat elected was elected in 1982, it was John Stennis who first been elected in 1946 as a segregationist, okay?

Keith Gaddie26:56Now he had evolved, and he was chairman of appropriations at one point, and we have an Air Force base named Afton in Southern Mississippi, the Stennis Air Base, right? It's part of US Space Command also. But yeah, you just don't think of it.

Andy Moore27:12Right, no, and- Yeah, you don't think of it. In that timeline, just about this race wasn't on anyone's radar until just a few weeks ago, I feel like that's the case for a lot of races, right? And people talk about, oh, well,

Andy Moore27:23we should have run more candidates, more places. Like, well, hindsight's always 2020. And also, you know, a year ago or two years ago, when a lot of these campaigns were starting, we, it was a very different environment. I don't think anyone would have guessed, right?

Andy Moore27:38That it was gonna go this way. And so it's just to see it kind of steadily build throughout this year has been really interesting.

Keith Gaddie27:44Now, you may recall a bunch of us were talking about this about a year ago, sorta. And, but this would take us back to Texas. Should we finish in Mississippi first?

Andy Moore27:56Sure, yeah, let's finish this.

Keith Gaddie27:56Okay, yeah. Well, no, it's important to finish this up because as of today, which is, today is the 6th of November? I think so. Yeah, November 6th.

Keith Gaddie28:04As of today, Mississippi is still counting and what's going on is, this is actually a part of electoral reform, okay? Yeah. We're still counting in Mississippi because electoral reform,

Keith Gaddie28:13we're still counting in Alaska because of electoral reform. So we have two Senate seats that are outstanding. In Mississippi, you have a five day grace period for mail-in ballots and provisional ballots to come in. And for provisional ballots, these are ballots

Keith Gaddie28:28that are cast contingent upon an individual demonstrating that they are registered to vote, right? So we have to go through all those and figure those out. Mail-in ballots are covered by the Military Overseas Voter Education Act, right? And so if they arrive within a certain window,

Keith Gaddie28:43they get counted. Now, there are, I think, I can't remember how many left over, I think it was 20,000 mail-in ballots that Mississippi has to count yet. A lot of these are overseas military ballots. And Colum feels very good about these

Keith Gaddie28:57because if you're an overseas military person voting in Mississippi, you're probably a young black person. Which means these are probably Democratic votes. So he's not looking at having his margin flipped by the mail-in vote. The provisional votes, who knows?

Keith Gaddie29:13But we have to count and examine these things for a few days. There'll be some efforts litigation because there always is. But in Mississippi, there is no automatic recount. There is no recount law in Mississippi.

Keith Gaddie29:26It doesn't mean you can't have a recount. There's simply no state law that requires it.

Andy Moore29:33Like there is, in Oklahoma there is, if it's within a certain percentage, it automatically goes to a manual recount.

Keith Gaddie29:38Exactly, exactly, but there's no mechanism to even, there's no known mechanism to step forward and ask for a recount, and in part because in Mississippi, Historically since 1818, why would you recount anything, right? Yeah, we had an election. It's done So you're done. So Mississippi may not be resolved for a few weeks potentially

Keith Gaddie30:00But the Democrats will look really good to potentially pick up that seat. The other thing is under the Mississippi Constitution statewide state offices Governor lieutenant governor so on they actually have a majority vote requirement So if this US Senate race were covered by the state constitution in the same matter as state constitutional offices, we'd be headed toward runoff. Because

Keith Gaddie30:25because the neither candidate has a 50% right. But that is not first I didn't even know this till I checked. I assume they had a runoff in place for those too. There was no runoff. So in Mississippi we're in the weird position of African-American voters simply mobilizing at roughly the same rate as Anglo-whites and Anglo-whites, not voting as heavily Republican as they would historically, have put this man into play, Scott Colum, as the front-runner right now to be the next

Keith Gaddie30:55U.S. Senator from Mississippi. But what you see going on in Mississippi is you see some evidence of what happened around the country. South of Memphis, there is a community called South Haven and Brookhaven. And they're both in a border county. They're a suburb of Memphis.

Keith Gaddie31:17It's White Flight County in Memphis. Historically very Republican, right? Yeah, voted Democratic this last week.

Andy Moore31:24And that's, isn't that Hyde-Smith's home county?

Keith Gaddie31:27It is, it is. Yeah, she's from Brookhaven, Mississippi.

Andy Moore31:30Can you, I mean, to lose your home county is, uh, gotta be a little embarrassing.

Keith Gaddie31:35It is, it is. And, um, but it tells you something, again, I'll do this in Texas. There's something that just went deep that's going on in general in the electorate and it's showing up in the South, it's showing up in the Midwest, it even showed up in Oklahoma, right? In a variety of constituencies, the Republican vote is off.

Keith Gaddie31:56You'll see people that point to an Oklahoma vote, a 21 point shift. It wasn't a 21 point shift, it was more like a six point shift. Something we need to do is you can't compare the gubernatorial vote in a state to the presidential vote, especially in Oklahoma, right? But what happened to Cindy Munson, who was a friend, if I have to come clear, Cindy Munson ran better than any Democrat has run in this state since David Walters as a non-incumbent.

Keith Gaddie32:26So there was a surge here for Democrats. And the Republican incumbent who won won by the lowest percentage of any Republican incumbent going back to the 1980s. So, but the places where the Democrats did better are these same kind of places, right? They're the suburbs, they're traditionally

Keith Gaddie32:46somewhat more affluent constituencies. They're growth suburbs, right? Inner residential communities in particular become much more blue in Oklahoma and elsewhere. So these are places that are like

Andy Moore33:00the Mississippi equivalent of like an Edmund, right?

Keith Gaddie33:03Yeah, exactly. That's the perfect metaphor.

Andy Moore33:06Yeah. I mean, it's not a surprise, I think, that places like Edmond and even West Oklahoma City out in like Bethany Warrick area, that those are the places we saw some of these seats flip. Not all of them, but Midwest City kind of the same deal. And I think to the extent that there is a median voter, median American voter, it's

Andy Moore33:32these like suburban, I haven't heard anyone say the term soccer mom yet. We'll wait and see. But it's those people that are probably a lot like you and I, they're the ones that made the big flip.

Keith Gaddie33:44Yeah, well, and so the metaphor in Texas, Taurico's target constituency was the wine mom. Actually, I think that's the soccer mom's 20 years in the past. That's actually the logical successor, right? It's the wine mom.

Keith Gaddie33:59And I'm fine with that. I can vote as a wine mom.

Andy Moore34:04And we've talked obviously about some of these candidates, but the racial demographics of voters, too, that we saw Latino and black voters vote more Democratic in pretty strong numbers. You mentioned that, like down in the Valley and Texas, right, all these voters.

Andy Moore34:20And to see, I saw some posts about some of the people down in the Valley and Texas with elaborate artwork elaborate artwork that they have created about governor-elect Inahosa and I was and it was very evident just from the coverage of like how much this woman as a candidate yeah to these people and now that she got elected and so and it was some like female artisans and so to see themselves in her with you just felt

Keith Gaddie34:49very powerful it was funny part of the research that me and my collaborator do is on public art and political art. And yeah, that's something we saw down there, is mural expression in support of this candidate. And so you're down in Brownsville, or you're down in Rio Grande City,

Keith Gaddie35:07or Edinburgh, or someplace like that. And you see this type of expression, and that's very telling, it's very telling. And that's a deep conceptualization of what's called linked fate. And linked fate argues that what happens

Keith Gaddie35:21to one member of our community happens to all of us. It's often viewed as being something negative. All of this injury happened to one of us, happened to all of us. It's also something positive. You saw this African-Americans in Barack Obama.

Keith Gaddie35:32You'll see this with Gina Hinojosa and the Mexican, and the Mexican, the Texian population. Let's get that word right. The Texian population, right? And that, that's telling, actually very affirmative,

Keith Gaddie35:47because it tells us about the future of Texas politics. And there are more Hispanics in Texas than any other racial or ethnic group. Now, a left-room of the state's only 37% Hispanic, right? But by population, it's about to become majority Hispanic. It may actually be there now.

Keith Gaddie36:05Oh, because the white majority has shrunk so much because of the groups that grow. Yeah, because the birth rate's much higher and it's a younger group among Hispanics. And the Anglo-white population has a much lower birth rate and is simply older.

Keith Gaddie36:20I'm not arguing for racial replacement theories, okay? It's just an empirical thing, okay? And there's a reason Republicans have been going after Hispanic voters for the last 35 years. They knew this was coming. They knew they had to create this constituency

Keith Gaddie36:37among Mexican-American voters. They thought they got there, but they gave it all back.

Andy Moore36:42So I'm Googling to pull up the numbers here because I have been talking about this with a few people about Oklahoma Yeah. And we'll get more into Oklahoma in a future episode, but the, I think, some of the reasons, this is my Andy's theory that I've developed in the last three days.

Keith Gaddie36:59Andy's three day theory, I like those. We should make a feature out of those.

Andy Moore37:04Every wild idea I have. Is that part of the reason that Oklahoma didn't, and to be clear, Oklahoma did move to the left in almost every county. Yeah. And, you know, Cindy Munson came very close to winning. Gina Nelson came even closer to winning.

Andy Moore37:19But Oklahoma is.

Keith Gaddie37:20She would have won under the old lines.

Andy Moore37:21Yeah. And if you would draw the lines really any other way, more fair I think. Yeah. Certainly the way that I drew them, which was a very fair way to draw it, but it was, I did not anticipate that, you know,

Andy Moore37:31Oklahoma County would look as blue this year as it did. Yeah. But Oklahoma overall is a fairly Caucasian state, right? Like the.

Keith Gaddie37:39Fifty-three, 54%.

Andy Moore37:41Yeah. White alone, so this is from the most recent Census Bureau, 58.7.

Keith Gaddie37:46Okay, so that's the American Community Survey data.

Andy Moore37:48Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Actually, it says 69.1, but that it's 58.7 for white alone, not included in the Hispanic Latino. Right.

Andy Moore37:55And then Native Americans are about nine, black is about eight, Asian is about three, and then Hispanic Latino of any race is about 14. And so compared to states like Mississippi and Texas that have much larger black and brown communities, Oklahoma's not quite that diverse. But if it was, I do wonder if we would have seen a different outcome in more of these races here.

Keith Gaddie38:22First of all, let's note that having a 42% non-Anglo white population is not inconsequential, okay? That means that you are a bit more diverse than America writ large, okay? That's not an inconsequential number, it's just that in Oklahoma, you have such a diversity

Keith Gaddie38:40of different non-Anglo white groups. And you don't have a history of high voter participation or cohesion in those groups. So your Native American vote has often been low, in part because tribal politics are more important, right? Participation in tribal politics is quite high, okay?

Keith Gaddie38:56For the Latino vote, less likely to have been long-term residential, less likely to be citizen, okay? So lower electorate, African American vote, traditionally it's just lagged and run lower, okay? So you have an electorate in Oklahoma that is probably 20 points more Anglo-White

Keith Gaddie39:14than the general population. That's what happens. Compare that to Georgia, which just became a non-majority anything state. African-American vote, Anglo-White vote turn out at the same rate.

Keith Gaddie39:27And the African-American vote's much more highly cohesive than the White vote. You chip away at White voter cohesion and you also get stronger turnout among the Asian-American populations places like Gwinnett County, DeKalb County, Fulton County, all that north side Atlanta

Keith Gaddie39:43arc, right, that arc on the north side of I-85. You put this all together, it's not that difficult to reach to create a Democratic majority in Georgia. John Ossoff had already done it, Raphael Warnock had done it, right? And now what did Georgians do with this? Georgia and Texas, the Democrats ran the table statewide for everything.

Keith Gaddie40:07No one saw that. We saw maybe the top. Ossoff had just enough mobilization effect and a big enough margin that it also activated for Lance Bottoms, right? And so Mayor Lance Bottoms, she becomes the governor-elect,

Keith Gaddie40:24but it rippled all the way down, it coattailed all the way in, and much like in Texas, Democrats took by the lower house of the Georgia General Assembly, right? In part because everybody turned down at comparable rates. Although, and behold, human beings

Keith Gaddie40:40who were eligible to vote voted, and we've been waiting for those for a long time, not necessarily for a Democratic majority or anything, we've just waited for everybody to be able to participate and show up, and Andy, all this happens. Skiing in the wake of efforts to constrain

Keith Gaddie40:56and knock back implementation of the Voting Rights Act. The more we have tried to constrain this act, the more we have emboldened voter participation voter turnout. The irony of this is it makes it that much harder to litigate against these changes in the laws being detrimental to voter participation. Doesn't mean you had to try extra hard, possibly. And imagine I'm being cagey, but probably.

Andy Moore41:21The same thing with gerrymandering, right? The Republicans clearly attempted to gerrymander half the country and it didn't work out. And even in states like Oklahoma where they They divided Oklahoma City into three congressional districts and made the fifth district, Stephanie Bison's district, one of the more conservative-leaning districts. And yet, here in this election, it almost flipped.

Andy Moore41:44Now, almost all of those votes that Gina Nelson received were in Oklahoma County and not in those rural counties that are also included in the district, but it does, in this argument against gerrymandering, when the wave is so powerful to overwhelm it, it does water down the argument against it.

Keith Gaddie41:59Yeah, and you know, for full context, Oklahoma County has been split three ways in the past. It had been split three ways by Democrats in the past. And they actually tried to argue in 2002 to keep it that way. And this other map was put into place.

Keith Gaddie42:15But we had not anticipated the bluing of Oklahoma County and Oklahoma City throughout the 21st century. Right. That's one thing. Second thing is Tinker has always been broken off and put in district four.

Keith Gaddie42:26It's been that way for over, nearly three quarters of a century. there's always been that break. But this last remap was quite consciously designed to protect Stephanie Bice. And it barely did its job.

Keith Gaddie42:38It barely did its job. And you have to wonder with the ongoing trends and growth in this county and in the city, and Oklahoma City is very different from the rest of the state, but it's also very prosperous, right?

Andy Moore42:51Well, and you saw, I mean, Mayor Holt came out of the gate on Wednesday very strong, making national headlines with his statements that, a political party that is, I think he said, morally and intellectually bankrupt, deserves to get beat, was a stark headline, even to those of us who know him. Yes.

Keith Gaddie43:10And I was like, whoa. Well, that just sounds like David. I mean, you know, it was just, hey, David Holt's still David Holt.

Andy Moore43:14This is wonderful, right? Yeah. And he and I, I mean, he was at our event on election night, and we had a few conversations in the few days prior. And about that sentiment of, and I think you see this in his rhetoric most of the time, is that Oklahoma City,

Andy Moore43:31Oklahoma County as well, which is somewhat synonymous, right? But Oklahoma City is doing really well compared to the rest of the state. Tulsa is doing fine. But I think he is correct in identifying that life in Oklahoma City is markedly different

Andy Moore43:45than it is in the rest of the state. And that is not derogatory to the rest of the state. It is a fact. And that some of that has to do with the policies and the way that governance happens in Oklahoma City. And I think his argument,

Andy Moore44:01I'm not to put words in his mouth, but I feel like his argument is, hey y'all, if the rest of the state, especially the state leaders, would begin to govern in a way that is similar to what we do in Oklahoma City,

Andy Moore44:13then this prosperity could be shared and not be isolated in the urban areas.

Keith Gaddie44:17Yeah, absolutely yes. And we've talked about this before. It's a very real, very true thing. And in order to be able to do that going forward, what has to happen is you need hyperfederalism, which means the state needs to leave some room

Keith Gaddie44:35for cities and counties to be who they are and to do these things, to take this initiative. And the state legislature in Oklahoma has been increasingly for the last decade, trying to actually constrain municipalities.

Andy Moore44:47Right, like the preemption laws and stuff.

Keith Gaddie44:49Yeah, the thing is there's this whole theory, it's actually called competitive federalism. And my co-author Tom Dye articulated it 60 years ago, which is you let localities put together a market basket of goods, services, policies, and priorities that will attract residents, right?

Keith Gaddie45:06And so you decide what kind of community you wanna be and then you create that environment. Now the upside is you can attract businesses, you can attract residents. The downside is you can also exclude residents, right? So you end up creating zoning laws

Keith Gaddie45:19that keep certain people out of a community or you make it hard to create rental properties or you don't have mass transit so you don't have non-car dependent people who are generally more middle and upper class, right? So there are two sides to this.

Keith Gaddie45:33But yeah.

Andy Moore45:35So this is not part of our plan for today, but it does peak something I've been thinking about for a while with this shift towards large, successful, economically growing, or at least stable municipalities, or like urban centers away from,

Andy Moore45:52this started because I was looking at some historical stuff about Oklahoma, and like the shift from a majority rural population to a majority urban population, and just this wondering of like, are we creating modern day city states, right?

Andy Moore46:05The Spartas and the Athens and that kind of thing, where Oklahoma City and the Metroplex in Dallas, New York City's been there for a long time. We know these big cities, and often these big cities, I mean New York City is a good example, where that is New York to most of the world.

Andy Moore46:22Now there's a whole other rest of the state up there as well, but if you had asked most people, would you rather be mayor of New York or governor of New York, most people are gonna pick mayor because that's the center, and the rest of the state

Keith Gaddie46:32just happens to be there. Yeah, I mean, remember, upstate is everything above Yonkers. Upstate starts real low. And let's go back to Texas for a minute, because we can talk about how this is happening in Oklahoma. Couple of things about Texas.

Keith Gaddie46:48The Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex is now physically defined as a metropolitan area by the Census Bureau as an area roughly the same size as Connecticut. But it has over twice as many people as Connecticut. And you've got five counties up there with at least a million people in them.

Keith Gaddie47:09McKinney and Collin County went Democratic. try that one on for size, right? But this is also part of a larger megalopolis that's growing up in Texas, where if you can draw a line from basically from Denton through Fort Worth,

Keith Gaddie47:22all the way down to San Antonio through Austin, then you draw a line over to Houston, over to Harris County, you draw another line up, up to Dallas, and then back into Denton again,

Keith Gaddie47:3275% of Texans live in that triangle, right? Because-

Andy Moore47:36There's five of the largest cities in the country,

Keith Gaddie47:37I think, that are in Texas, right? Are all in there, and they're all in the triangle. And it's increasingly all kind of molding together where it's just one constant suburban to urban traffic jam. Okay, you know, it's almost as heat of a fly to Austin as it is to drive there from Dallas anymore.

Keith Gaddie47:57But in Oklahoma, first of all, the second thing is the DFW Metroplex actually comes into Oklahoma now.

Andy Moore48:05Oh, the metro area that jumped across the river down there at Durand.

Keith Gaddie48:09Yeah, so that's now part of urban Dallas.

Andy Moore48:11Which is part of why I think the president went there for his visit. But that whole merging of urban centers is not dissimilar from what the way the East Coast has been for a while, right? I have friends who work in D.C. but will travel to Baltimore or whatever on the train pretty regularly. And I talk to them, like, we'll do Zoom calls while they're on the train, traveling between

Andy Moore48:36cities in a way that we Midwesterners cannot fathom. But it's the same kind of thing.

Keith Gaddie48:42It's one big, continuous city area. And the thing is Oklahoma can attach to this. I mean, I'm a resident of Texas now, have a home in Texas, but I'm up here a good bit. And my whole plan originally was I'll just be about back and forth on the Heartland Flyer. And I could be doing those Zoom calls on the Heartland Flyer and never drive my truck

Keith Gaddie49:03back and forth, except there's no wireless on the damn train, okay? And the phone service is sufficiently bad because Texas and Oklahoma can't agree on how to pay for it. But as you get heavy rail into Oklahoma, you regularize this kind of commuting, it's only going to intensify the urbanization and the growth of the Oklahoma City metropolis. And invariably it's going to grow towards Tulsa, and Tulsa's going to gravitate this way. And you're going end up with this hockey stick. Let's go from Tulsa through Oklahoma with this big hinge.

Keith Gaddie49:33Oklahoma State with a big hinge. And it's going to make its way down I-35. It's funny, Ed Kelly, the old editor of the Oklahoma, and I talked about this for years. Invariably this will happen because residential Texas is leaping the Red River. And it's going to come up the interstate. And the development's coming up that corridor.

Andy Moore49:55Which is funny to me, because if you look at a map from, I don't know, 1885, and you look at where American migration was, the cities popped up along the rail lines, because that was the transportation back then. And so you started to have those cities, and then later, by the 1950s, you've got Eisenhower and the interstate system, which didn't exactly follow the railroads, but similar in a lot of places like I-35 and those Amtrak lines.

Andy Moore50:27And so it seemed like we built our country along these rail lines. And then cars came along. We were able to spread out and start these little towns. And then as the railroad died, a lot of those towns died. And now we're like redoing the same thing.

Andy Moore50:44And it's just real funny to kind of see us grow in the same areas that we did 100 years ago. But now we're doing it for different reasons.

Keith Gaddie50:52Yeah, yeah, and you know, it's funny, all this Andy, because I'm going to take us back towards where we've been talking. The funny thing about all this, as we go through all these things, we talked about these initiatives, these priorities, these opportunities, because this is how Texas has grown. It's how Georgia and Atlanta have grown. It's always

Keith Gaddie51:07been about transportation and the integrated movement and economic development. You know what never ever comes up in this conversation? Trans athletes. Yet, in the closing week of the campaign in Texas, $79 million was dumped into the Texas campaign on trans athletes and it moved nothing because culture war died at least for one election cycle in this last election because of kitchen table issues because

Keith Gaddie51:44of the reaction to national government overreach and because of a negative

Andy Moore51:48reaction to anger in politics. Yeah. Yeah. It's, you know, the

Keith Gaddie51:54playbook played out. It exhausted itself. Yeah. And the electorate looked at it and said, ah, nah, we're done playing with that. Right. Yeah. And the polling, the polling will back that up. Yeah. Imagine the polling missed again. It got the direction right. Mm hmm. It just didn't get the magnitude right. Yeah. And I think this is important to note. As long

Keith Gaddie52:15as polls get the direction right, I think the public has Satisfied with polling yes 100% you can miss on the magnitude Yeah, because a miss is as good as a model right right, but yeah, just get get the direction right and that's enough Yeah, the rest is just That yeah, it's not Yeah, it's just it's um. It's Wednesday morning quarterbacking right yeah, yeah

Keith Gaddie52:37No, but it being yeah being yeah being six points off in the correct direction It's forgivable, but six points in the wrong way is you were way wrong Yeah, and that's probably you tell people that are gonna get ice cream for dinner and then they don't Right irrespective of what kind of ice cream you like which kind of dinner you like Torture that metaphor. Sorry about that But yeah, if you're a Republican and you're told you're gonna lose and then you win you're happy

Keith Gaddie53:01But if you're told you're gonna win and you lose you're unhappy right Democrats are the same way Yeah, and I blame the media for the misuse on the product of what used to be my industry. Okay? Okay. Polls explain to you why people make choices. They're not meant to predict precisely because we don't know the turnout model.

Keith Gaddie53:21Sure. So there, I got that one done in record space.

Andy Moore53:24That was good. As we kind of wrap up, any, looking at the map, I think the other, go with any other final thoughts. My final thought is an interesting data point that there is all this conversation with the South because the South did over-perform

Andy Moore53:40in ways that were pretty remarkable. Up north though, states like Minnesota, with Peggy Flanagan and even Michigan with Al Said's race, while they won, they didn't win as big as they were protected. So this is where the polls were also wrong in magnitude,

Andy Moore53:59but the other direction, they just still happened to get the right direction where we saw, and some of it is that turnout wasn't as high up there, I think, maybe has to do with the demographics of the electorate up there as well. But do you think, I'd be curious just what your thoughts are

Andy Moore54:17on those geographic, like regional differences.

Keith Gaddie54:20Well, you know, the South is, the areas where the Democrats surge in the South, with the exception of, well, they did surge a bit in Florida, but it just didn't have as nearly as big an impact. Rather, the outcomes were not in the direction

Keith Gaddie54:35had hoped for, but they continued to jump even further ahead in Virginia. They completely upset North Carolina. The gerrymander backfired there. They took the Senate seat in South

Andy Moore54:48Carolina. Just wild. The fact that the Republicans lost South Carolina is shocking to me.

Keith Gaddie54:55Well, appointed U.S. Senators who run in their own right lose 70% of the time. So, Intergrams, loss, in the context of broader history is to be completely expected. In part because appointed senators are not usually particularly good candidates. So there's that piece.

Keith Gaddie55:16But South Carolina moves that direction because even though South Carolina's growing older, it's because it's a retirement destination. Georgia, again, surge and Democratic. Texas, surge and Democratic. It's economically surging.

Keith Gaddie55:33population searching. So the high growth parts of the south all went to the left in terms of outcome, not just in terms of vote direction, but in terms of choice. And the Democrats came within about a point and a half of winning the governorship in Florida. So that's a huge improvement of where they've been in the past. So everything moved in the direction you'd expect. But for the rest of the country, Minnesota, Michigan, Wisconsin, for the Democrats did well. These are not growth areas, right? And we're continuing to struggle with certain

Keith Gaddie56:09issues of the deflation of the population in the economy of Michigan and Ohio and Minnesota. Illinois is a remarkable problem in and of itself Missouri. And we don't know where their politics goes, but maybe a bizarre situation where if the Democrats become the party of both diversity and growth and performance. They end up becoming a more southern party. And maybe the old rust belt goes back towards the GOP again.

Andy Moore56:38Right. Yeah. How funny. What a world.

Keith Gaddie56:42We're gonna have to live it out.

Andy Moore56:43Well, I guess we'll find out. Some good elections. The, yeah, well, there's still lots of data, I think, to unpack. We're just a few days in. I haven't caught up on sleep yet from Tuesday.

Andy Moore56:54And so, Keith, thank you for being here and helping us kind of break down what happened in America on Tuesday.

Keith Gaddie56:59Good to be here, Andy, always.

Andy Moore57:02You wanna do this again soon? Yeah, please. Yeah, let's, we'll find a time to do this. The next few weeks, I think for a lot of people who work in and around politics, or lots of vacations, or just trying to get away,

Andy Moore57:14start planning for the holidays.

Keith Gaddie57:15Now let me ask you, you've got NANR coming up the beginning of December, is that right?

Andy Moore57:19I do, yes, that's my, for me, my life shifts from planning a cheese rave to planning this other conference that we'll be at in December, so. And that's a separate podcast altogether, but electoral reform was on the ballot and a lot of states this year were obviously

Andy Moore57:35still waiting to see the outcome in Alaska with yet another repeal effort on the ranked choice voting up there. Although, oddly enough, ranked choice voting may actually work for the opponents of ranked choice voting in Alaska,

Andy Moore57:44which it's been a delicious season for irony.

Keith Gaddie57:48It really has. Irony has had the best possible workout this year.

Andy Moore57:51Yeah, for sure. All right, well, listeners, thank you for being here as well, as always. Every week we say decisions are made by those who show up. And that was certainly the case this week.

Andy Moore58:02We'll have another episode very soon with my regular co-host with Emily Stacy, talking about what happened in Oklahoma and kind of digging into the local and state races here and the low turnout that we saw this year as well. And then for the next few weeks, I'll just be honest,

Andy Moore58:18like it might be a bit bumpy. We may not have an episode every week. I hope that's okay with you as you plan for the holidays and make time for your families as well. But please, if you have questions, reach out. and email and podcast at letsfixthis.org anytime.

Andy Moore58:32Thank you for listening. Please like and subscribe and do all those things you do. Have a good week.

All blog posts